Not a member? Why not join us or log in? (No more hassle filling in comments, less obtrusive ads and asides.)

When Distinctions ain’t so Distinct

Posted by Phil Renaud on March 1st, 2006.

Phil Renaud is a Canadian blog design and web design enthusiast, with a particular admiration for web standards and CSS innovation. Ruby on Rails, xhtml/css, ajax, and a whole lotta love.

http://philrenaud.com

Phil Renaud has posted 21 articles.

RSS Feed for fadtastic.net RSS Feed for Phil Renaud

Full Profile →

A case can be made that web professionals thrive on competition: different schools of thought on web development emerge and almost immediately compare themselves as being superior to predecessors/rivals (ie: “rails is like php, only maintainable”; “my flash app can do what your java app never could”).

It’s becoming a bit troubling, you see. Now communities of web professionals are springing up faster than religious denominations during the renaissance, and no two have stood in such stark contrast as the front-end designers and the server-side coders, and for years, it seemed that one hardly cared about what the other was doing.

The good news? It looks like that’s all begun to change.

The new web (2.0 now?) seems to be dedicated to creating pleasant user-experience above all else, and all parties have reached the agreement that this cannot be achieved without both design that is visually appealing, and efficiently functioning code. So, what are we seeing in response to this revelation? Are we finding that server-side profficient companies are adding new offices for designers? Are seeing design firms having a new respect for computer engineers with development sensibilities?

No! Even better news!

We’re seeing the emergence of a sort of web Renaissance Man! A design-minded coder! A code-minded designer! The prototypical Übermensch of our time!

Alright, maybe I’m taking it a bit far here, but man! What do you say when you see an aesthetically-minded company like Apple putting out a tutorial for Ruby on Rails?

It’s not like technology is slowing down and giving us more time to learn technologies on both fronts, either: things are emerging at as rapid a pace as they ever have, and there is a very real demand for individuals who can keep up with both working the client and server side aspects of web development.

So what do you think? Are firms better off shelling out cash for seperate design and development personel? Or is the turn towards the department full of people equally suited for both tasks something admirable?

(PS: It occurs to me that I’ve invoked both Nietzsche and Renaissance-era theological development into a post about web development - you’re welcome).

Make A Comment

( 7 so far )

blockquote and a tags work here.

7 Responses to When Distinctions ain’t so Distinct

Comments RSS Feed

I think the upcoming years will show how valuable the creative coder is. While I think you always need the specialists, you need the well-rounded individuals to act as the glue to bring the designer and the coder together.

P.J. Onori
March 1st, 2006
#

Reminds me of start learning server-side.

Tor Bollingmo
March 1st, 2006
#

This is why I got into web design in the first place, albeit recently. The pinnacle of my artistic ability was paint-by-numbers, so it was a no-brainer to want to learn front- and back-side coding for web design.

Good article. Here’s to the well-rounded.

Andrew W
March 1st, 2006
#

Awww? I’ve been a design-minded developer for a long time now, and it’s helped me stand out among the competition. Now I’m just one of the flock :(

Okay. I’m over it. :)

Michael McCorry
March 1st, 2006
#

I believe that to really succeed anymore, one must be able to do just about everything, from design, to coding the CMS. We must be flexible, to survive.

It’s too bad though I don’t have any of those qualities (sigh).

Steven Teskey
March 4th, 2006
#

[…] Fadtastic discusses some distinctions that sometimes, aren’t so distinct when making judgements about web professionals. […]

This is a really critical topic with me right now. I’m looking for a change of job, and the “Renaissance Man” phenomenon is playing a bigger role than I would like.

Background: got A’s in Art. Failed Math. Got a BFA Hons and became a graphic designer to pay the bills until the being-an-artist thing paid off.

I’ve been a designer for 4.5 years. In that time I’ve seen the job description grow to encompass more than anyone could possibly be good at in that time span. About 2 years ago employers suddenly expected designers to be WEB designers. An entirely separate branch of design (as different, IMO, as industrial design) that required some very specific practice with user-centred principles & information architecture. Fine though, we learned. Now I’m out hunting for a job again, and all that experience is just basic - now web designers are expected to be programmers. “Familiarity with ASP.NET” my arse. I’m familiar with it to the extent that I pick up lunch for the programmer sometimes.

Right now I’m reading this in HTML/XHTML class @ the local community college, and that’s taking away from billable time I could be working on an illustration contract for a major magazine that’s due in 2 weeks. Every minute I spend exercising the left side of my brain, I’m neglecting the right.

This is stretching us pretty thin and causing a “jack-of-all-trades, master of none” issue - yes employers would like us to be able to do everything, but how GOOD will we be at any of it? Maybe it’s easier for programmers to adopt some sense of style (the rise of CSS has shown that both sides of the brain function in many talented individuals) but from our side, anyway, I think artists are left unable to develop to their potential because of technical demands.

All that aside - I LOVE the situation we’re developing now wherein, in the best environments, programmers and designers see that they’re there to accomplish the same goals. My husband owns a web development company, and he really values creativity in his programmers. That doesn’t have to come in the form of design sense. It can and SHOULD be a whole other world of functional creativity.

Erica
April 12th, 2006
#

↑ Jump up to the comment form

Related In Some Way, Shape Or Form

The above post has obviously kept you amused. Why not discover similar material:

The posts Ten Design Resources for OctoberAre ads okay yet?Style on the web, style in the real world.What Came First - Form Or Function?Where Are The Female Designers?, are related to this post.

Or why not take time out to find out about the author of the post.